If you’re a fan of Crumbl Cookies, but not the biggest fan of spending $5 a cookie, I’ve got the perfect solution with these ten delicious Crumbl Cookie copycat recipes!
Crumbl has definitely exploded in popularity. With their iconic pink boxes and their extra large and loaded cookies, it’s no wonder people go absolutely bonkers for this rapidly growing cookie chain.
Aside from their signature-sized cookies, Crumbl is also known for their endless array of cookie flavors. Every single week, they rotate different flavors, and they’re constantly coming up with new ones. The only problem is that these cookies can be on the spendier side, coming out at around $5 cookie. Even though they are big cookies, I have a hard time spending that much money on ONE cookie, especially when I can make my own at home. Speaking of…
Over the past few years, I’ve created and compiled my own list of Crumbl Cookie copycat recipes. And not to toot my own sax or anything, but I personally believe that my cookies taste and look WAY better. (Sorry, Crumbl!) So if you’re a Crumbl Cookie fiend who’d rather not break the bank, I highly recommend giving one, two, or ALL of these cookie recipes a try!
#1. Hostess Cupcake Cookies – These cookies contain ALL of the delicious elements of the classic Hostess Cupcake. With a super soft and THICC chocolate cookie, fluffy marshmallow frosting, and rich chocolate ganache, these cookies are a Hostess lover’s dream come true!
#2. Key Lime Pie Cookies – This cookie has a graham cracker cookie base that’s topped with a refreshingly tart key lime pie filling, whipped cream, and a cute little key lime wedge!
#3. Pecan Pie Cookies – These cookies contain all of the deliciousness of a traditional slice of pecan pie and MORE!! Because not only does it have the divinely decadent ooey gooey brown sugar pecan filling we all salivate over, but instead of a boring ol’ pie crust, it has a soft and buttery sugar cookie!
#4. Cinnamon Roll Cookies – These Cinnamon Roll Cookies taste exactly like a cinnamon roll, but in sugar cookie form! Each and every delectable cookie contains that same brown sugar cinnamon swirl we all swoon over as well as that dreamy cream cheese frosting we just can’t get enough of.
#5. Raspberry Cheesecake Cookies – This Crumbl copycat has all of the delicious elements of a rich slice of raspberry cheesecake–a graham cracker-infused cookie base, tangy cream cheese frosting, and a sweet raspberry drizzle.
#6. Frosted Circus Animal Cookies – Soft, chewy, and brimming with sprinkles, cake batter, and white chocolate sweetness, these Frosted Circus Animal Cookies are guaranteed to be a hit for young and old alike!
#7. Strawberry Lemonade Cookies – With a deliciously thick and chewy lemon cookie base slathered in both lemon AND strawberry buttercream, these Strawberry Lemonade Cookies are guaranteed to captivate those taste buds of yours.
#8. Pumpkin Sugar Cookies – Soft and chewy sugar cookies topped with the most heavenly pumpkin buttercream frosting!
#9. Twix Sugar Cookies – These Twix Sugar Cookies are beyond delectable. They’re like biting into the freshest Twix bar ever! Because instead of a crunchy biscuit-like cookie, you have a deliciously thick and buttery sugar cookie. It’s not overly sweet, making it the perfect base to go under a generous slathering of vanilla buttercream, or in this case, caramel and chocolate.
#10. Red Velvet Sugar Cookies – These Red Velvet Sugar Cookies are SO much more than simple frosted sugar cookies. They’re ultra soft, wonderfully thick, perfectly moist and slightly chewy. Not the least bit cakey or crumbly.
